$25 Million Ethereum MEV Wire Fraud Case Ends with Acquittal for Anton and James Peraire-Bueno

A federal judge in Manhattan has entered a judgment of acquittal for two brothers who graduated from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, ending a novel prosecution that accused them of extracting roughly $25 million in cryptocurrency in about twelve seconds.

U.S. District Judge Jessica G. L. Clarke ruled on November 16, 2026, that prosecutors failed to prove the essential elements of wire fraud, conspiracy to commit wire fraud, and conspiracy to commit money laundering.

Anton Peraire-Bueno and James Peraire-Bueno, both computer programmers, were indicted in May 2024.

The case arose from events on April 23, 2023, on the Ethereum network.

Prosecutors alleged the brothers executed a strategy they called “Omakase.”

They sent carefully crafted lure or bait transactions designed to attract automated trading bots that specialized in sandwich trading.

Sandwich trading involves bots detecting pending trades and inserting their own orders immediately before and after them to capture small price differences created by those trades.

According to the government, the brothers exploited a vulnerability in MEV-Boost, open-source software widely used by Ethereum validators to maximize the value of blocks they propose to the blockchain. MEV-

Boost implements a form of proposer-builder separation that is meant to keep the contents of proposed blocks private from validators until after they commit to proposing them.

The alleged flaw allowed the brothers to view transactions that sandwich bots believed were private, then substitute their own replacement transactions.

This prevented the bots from completing their intended trades and caused them to lose more than $25 million in a matter of seconds while the brothers captured the corresponding value.

The brothers were long-time participants in the Ethereum ecosystem.

They had traded extensively on the network and provided technical support and infrastructure.

After the incident, they were arrested in May 2024.

Their trial in the Southern District of New York began in October 2025 and lasted nearly four weeks.

In early November 2025 the jury was unable to reach a unanimous verdict on any count, and Judge Clarke declared a mistrial.

Defense lawyers later moved for a judgment of acquittal under Rule 29 of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure.In a 46-page opinion, Judge Clarke emphasized that the court was not deciding whether the brothers’ conduct was ethical, proper, or even whether it might have violated other uncharged laws.

The sole question was whether the evidence, viewed in the light most favorable to the government, could support convictions for the specific charges brought.

Wire fraud requires proof of a material misrepresentation or omission.

The judge found that prosecutors had not shown any such material false statement or deception in the brothers’ transactions.

The court noted that the relevant activity occurred on a decentralized, permissionless blockchain rather than on a regulated exchange or market that prohibits certain forms of order manipulation.

Comparisons to practices such as spoofing, which are barred by rules on traditional markets, therefore did not apply.

The judge also rejected arguments that a falsified block signature, the brothers’ operation of a validator, concealment of their identities, or the overall scheme itself could substitute for a specific material misrepresentation.

Because the wire-fraud theory failed, the dependent money-laundering conspiracy count also could not stand.

The ruling closes a case that prosecutors had described as the first of its kind, testing whether sophisticated trading strategies that exploit software vulnerabilities on public blockchains can be prosecuted as wire fraud when no traditional market rules are violated and no clear misrepresentation is proven.

Defense attorneys had maintained throughout that the brothers’ actions constituted legitimate, if aggressive, competition within the norms and incentive structures of the Ethereum network.

With the judgment of acquittal entered on all counts, the brothers avoid a retrial.

The decision underscores the challenges of applying long-standing fraud statutes to highly technical activity on decentralized networks, where participants operate under code, economic incentives, and community norms rather than formal regulatory rules.



Sponsored Links by DQ Promote

 

 

Disclosure Quest

Reg A - Form 1-A Filings Beta

Beta. Initial Form 1-A only. Target raise is the stated Amount to be Raised, totaled. Compared with the same dates one year earlier.

YTD: Jan 1, 2026 - Nov 17, 2026 vs Jan 1, 2025 - Nov 17, 2025

Share this graph
Number of Filings138Prior 131 +5.3%
Target Raise, Total$3.49BPrior $3.62B -3.7%
This YTDYear priorChange
Filings 138 131 +5.3%
Target raise $3.49B $3.62B -3.7%

Sponsored by the Crowded Media Group the leading digital news service covering the global Fintech Industry, including digital assets, crowdfunding, tokenization, and other innovations in capital markets. email us @CrowdfundInside

Source: DisclosureQuest. Initial Form 1-A only.

Created by Crowded Media Group

This display counts initial Form 1-A filings only. It does not represent subsequent filings, including Form 1-A/A amendments or Form 1-A POS post-qualification updates filed by the issuer. Amounts are the stated Amount to be Raised on the initial filing, not capital raised and not amounts revised in later filings.

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

0 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
 
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x
Send this to a friend